The Best Line Length

Summary

What’s a good maximum line length for your coding standard? This is, of course, a trick question. By posing it as a question, I have created the misleading impression that it is a question, but Black has selected the correct number for you; it’s 88 which is obviously very lucky. Thanks for reading my blog. OK, OK. Clearly, there’s more to it than that. This is an age-old debate on the level of “tabs versus spaces”. So contentious, in fact, that even the famously opinionated Black does in fact let you change it. Ancient History One argument that certain silly people like to make is “why are we wrapping at 80 characters like we are using 80 character teletypes, it’s the 2020s! I have an ultrawide monitor!”. The implication here is that the width of 80-character terminals is an antiquated relic, based entirely around the hardware limitations of a bygone era, and modern displays can put tons of stuff on one line, so why not use that capability? This feels intuitively true, given the huge disparity between ancient times and now: on my own display, I can comfortably fit about 350 characters on a line. What a shame, to have so much room for so many characters in each line, and to waste it all on blank space! But... is that true? I stretched out my editor window all the way to measure that ‘350’ number, but I did not continue editing at that window width. In order to have a more comfortable editing experience, I switched back into writeroom mode, a mode which emulates a considerably more writerly application, which limits each line length to 92 characters, regardless of frame width. You’ve probably noticed this too. Almost all sites that display prose of any kind limit their width, even on very wide screens. As silly as that tiny little ribbon of text running down the middle of your monitor might look with a full-screened stereotypical news site or blog, if you full-screen a site that doesn’t set that width-limit, although it makes sense that you can now use all that space ...