Roko's Dancing Basilisk

https://news.ycombinator.com/rss Hits: 3
Summary

I came across a reference to DeepWiki, a site that will generate “documentation” for any Github repository. I can't say I've been impressed with LLMs generating code, but what about documentation? I haven't tried that yet. Let's see how well Roko's basilisk dances! Intially, I started with mod_blog. I've been working with the codebase now for 26 years so it should be easy for me to spot inaccuracies in the “documentation.” Even better—there's no interaction with a sycophantic chat bot; just plop in the URL for the repo, supply an email for notification when it's done and as the Brits say, “Bob's your uncle!” Anyway, email came. I checked, and I was quickly amazed! Nearly 30 pages of documentation, and the overview was impressive. It picked up on tumblers, the storage layout, the typical flows in adding a new entry. It even got the fact that cmd_cgi_get_today() returns all the entries for a given day of the month throughout the years. But there was one bit that was just a tad bit off. It stated “[t]he system consists of three primary layers” but the following diagram showed five layers, which no indication of what three were the “primary layers.” I didn't have a problem with the layers it did identify: Entry Layer Processing Layer Rendering Layer Storage Layer Configuration Just that it seems to have a problem counting to three. Before I get into a review of the rest of the contents, I'll mention briefly my opinions on the web site as interface: it's meh. The menu on the left is longer than it appears, given that scroll bars seem oh so last century (really! I would love to force “web designers” to use old-fasioned three-button mice and a monitor calibrated to simulate color-blindness, just to see them strugge with their own designs; not everyone has a mouse with a scroll-wheel, nor an Apple Trackpad). Also, the diagrams are very inconsistent, and often times, way too small to view properly, even when selected. Then you'll get the occasionally gigantic diagram. The la...

First seen: 2025-12-06 07:19

Last seen: 2025-12-06 09:19